Technical Review of the Second National Assessment of Environmental Effects Monitoring Data

The Metal Mining Effluent Regulation (MMER) requires metal mines in Canada to conduct Environmental Effects Monitoring (EEM) to assess the potential effects of mine effluent on receiving waters and their resident biota on a national basis. The EEM program (Environment Canada 2011) provides a framework for the consistent collection of data on five endpoints regarding fish health, and four endpoints regarding benthic invertebrate community structure. For fish health, the endpoints are condition, liver size, gonad size, weight-at-age, and age, and for benthic invertebrate-community structure the endpoints are density, taxon richness, the Bray-Curtis Index (BCI) and Simpson’s evenness. The stated primary goal is to determine if the MMER effluent regulations, on a national basis, are (on average) protective of the receiving environment (Environment Canada 2012).

Environment Canada has interpreted the national EEM data and concluded that measurable environmental impacts are being caused by individual mines and the mining industry at large (Lowell et al. 2006, Environment Canada 2012). The Mining Association of Canada (MAC) is concerned about the technical validity and strength of Environment Canada’s interpretation of the EEM data. Previously MAC retained independent technical expertise to review the scientific validity of Environment Canada’s administration of the Metal Mining Effluent Regulations (MMER), especially on a site-specific basis. Findings of errors and systematic bias in the interpretation of the EEM data resulted in publications documenting these findings in respected aquatic toxicology journals (Huebert et al. 2011; Huebert 2012a, b). The findings also encouraged discussion between MAC and Environment Canada in December 2011 to attempt resolution of the identified issues. The findings included a pseudo-replicated basic study design, incorrect designation of experiment-wise error, and biased calculation of the Bray-Curtis Index.

Related Resources

Guides & Manuals  | 
Since the first edition of the Guide was published in 1998, the tailings management framework has been applied at mining operations across Canada and around the world. During this time,[...]

Popular Resources

Report  | 
MAC’s annual flagship publication detailing the latest trends in the Canadian mining industry.

Canadian Mining Stories

The sector is a major economic driver in our Canadian economy and a great contributor to jobs and leading technologies and here are our stories. 

Dominion Diamond / Traditional Knowledge Elders Group

Indigenous Traditional Knowledge is transforming how we mine At Dominion Diamond’s Ekati mine in the Northwest Territories, located just 200 kilometres south of the Arctic Circle, the Traditional Knowledge Elders...

Yelda Temizci

Eldorado Gold Corporation’s Yelda Temizci works as a CAT truck driver at the company’s Kisladag gold mine in Turkey and was the first female rock truck driver in the entire...

Subscribe to MAC News


*Indicates a required field

You can unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more information on how to unsubscribe, our privacy practices, and how we are committed to protecting and respecting your privacy, please review our Privacy Policy.

By clicking submit, you consent to allow The Mining Association of Canada to store and process the personal information submitted above to provide you the content requested.