Third-Party Report on the Second National Assessment of Environmental Effects Monitoring

Prepared by Shinichi Nakagawa, PhD., for the Mining Association of Canada, July 2012.

Environment Canada (EC) recently released a report titled “Second National Assessment of Environmental Effects Monitoring Data from Metal Mines Subjected to the Metal Mining Effluent Regulations” (hereafter called, the 2nd assessment). In this report, EC presented several statistically significant and negative impacts of mining effluent on fish and invertebrate communities. In the light of the results reported in the 2nd assessment, Mining Association Canada (MAC) sought independent reviews. MAC asked Dr David Huebert (Stantec Consulting Ltd.) to write an independent review on the 2nd assessment. I (Dr Shinichi Nakagawa, University of Otago) have also been asked to provide an independent review on the 2nd assessment. At the same time, I have been asked to review Dr Huebert’s evaluation (hereafter called, Stantec’s assessment).

As a third party and independent review, the aim of the current review is to assess both the 2nd assessment and Stantec’ assessment. My evaluation will focus on whether the  analyses employed in these two reports were technically and statistically sound and also whether the stated conclusions of the two reports were appropriate given the results. As the two reports show, disagreements between these two parties (i.e. EC and Stantec) reside almost exclusively in their interpretations of the meta-analytic results, which EC presented in the 2nd assessment. Therefore, I concentrate my review on the metaanalytic methods EC used and the interpretations of meta-analytic results by these two parties. This report have three main parts: (i) an evaluation of the 2nd assessment, (ii) an evaluation of Stantec’s assessment and (iii) a brief concluding section.

Related Resources

Report  | 
Executive summary The transition to a low carbon economy, as well as changing technology and[...]

Popular Resources

Report  | 
MAC’s annual flagship publication detailing the latest trends in the Canadian mining industry.

Canadian Mining Stories

The sector is a major economic driver in our Canadian economy and a great contributor to jobs and leading technologies and here are our stories. 

Robin Hebbard

Suncor heavy equipment operator Robin Hebbard led a charge to expand female locker rooms at the Aurora oil sands mine after a growing women’s workforce led to a lack of...

Jody Kopp

Jody Kopp, Cameco’s Senior Coordinator of Nursing Services, was instrumental in COVID-19 response planning and ensures safety for all employees – she previously worked as an Occupational Health Nurse in...

Subscribe to MAC News

"*" indicates required fields


*Indicates a required field

You can unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more information on how to unsubscribe, our privacy practices, and how we are committed to protecting and respecting your privacy, please review our Privacy Policy.

By clicking submit, you consent to allow The Mining Association of Canada to store and process the personal information submitted above to provide you the content requested.