Digging Deeper: Understanding the Disclosure Disconnect in the Mining Sector

As the ESG space becomes more sophisticated, ESG disclosure becomes more complex. With a staggering number of reporting frameworks, initiatives and questionnaires, issuers and investors alike are struggling to understand how these elements interact.

In April 2020, Millani conducted a perception study of  Canadian institutional investors to understand their view on the potential impact the COVID-19 pandemic would have on ESG. The study predicted that ESG will be here to stay. It specifically emphasized that markets were seeing the connection between financial value and the social topics that were rapidly being brought forward by
the pandemic, and that investor engagement on these topics would likely increase, to better understand the strategy and management of these topics. During the summer of 2020, MAC conducted a similar survey with its members. Mining companies agreed that there is a growing interest from investors on social topics and believed that their current operational approaches to these topics were effective. The survey also underscored a lack of alignment on the level of disclosure being provided: investors are requesting additional context to social disclosure but are facing challenges taking into account data provided by mining companies, which is often facility and issuer-specific.

Part of the disconnect between investors and mining companies seems to stem from the fact that the former seeks the “Why?” behind the data, whereas the latter had previously been focused on providing the “How?”. As investors are implementing more and more proprietary models to assess ESG topics, the need for raw data from corporate issuers is growing. That being said, investors are also looking for context to understand the trends behind the data. This context helps investors understand why the topic itself and the data being measured are important to the company – in other words, why they are material.

As part of an ongoing roundtable series, Millani Inc. and MAC brought mining companies and a group of Canadian institutional investors together to dig deeper on the perceived disconnect between issuers’ disclosure, and investors’ disclosure needs.

Related Resources

Report  | 
A contact sheet for all TSM Verification Service Providers in January 2019.

Popular Resources

Report  | 
MAC’s annual flagship publication detailing the latest trends in the Canadian mining industry.

Canadian Mining Stories

The sector is a major economic driver in our Canadian economy and a great contributor to jobs and leading technologies and here are our stories. 

Angela Hamlyn

As CEO of the Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum, Angela Hamlyn leads the organization dedicated to the advancement of knowledge, celebration of excellence and promotion of sustainable practices...

Lesley Joy

As Vale’s Long Harbour Processing Plant General Manager, Lesley Joy leads a team of approximately 1,000 people who sustainably produce high quality nickel, cobalt and copper products. Lesley has over...

Subscribe to MAC News

"*" indicates required fields


*Indicates a required field

You can unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more information on how to unsubscribe, our privacy practices, and how we are committed to protecting and respecting your privacy, please review our Privacy Policy.

By clicking submit, you consent to allow The Mining Association of Canada to store and process the personal information submitted above to provide you the content requested.